How Dependable Are AI’s Predictive Skills? & How Should Weak Dependencies Be Managed?

Monday, 01 December 2025
By Bob McDowall

robot fortune teller

The way in which AI’s predictive skills are presented are based on its ability to use historical and real-time data to (allegedly) forecast future outcomes, events, and trends with a high degree of accuracy.

AI providers would assert that its predictive capabilities are delivered through the identification of complex patterns and relationships within massive datasets, which are impossible for human analysts deliver to find manually, certainly on any practical timely basis.

AI’s predictive attributes may be summarised in order of importance as

1) Using the past as the basis for predicting the future – this is done through:

  • Pattern Recognition, where AI has the capability to identify and reveal subtle, arcane patterns and correlations within vast amounts of data, using machine learning and deep learning algorithms.
  • Data-Driven Forecasting, where predictions are based on statistical analysis of data, leading to more objective and informed in contrast to human intuition or guesswork

2) Logistical capabilities, i.e.

  • Continuous learning and adaptation – This enables the delivery of continual and recurring predictive AI models. These models derive their capabilities from new data inputs over time. continually improving their accuracy and relevance as conditions change.
  • Automation and Speed - The high speed processing of data and rapid modelling enable real-time predictions and immediate responses to events and emerging situations.
  • Scalability - AI models can process and analyse large and diverse datasets from various sources. These include sensor data, financial records, and even social media, at scale.

3) Risk management, through:

  • Risk Mitigation - delivered by identifying potential problems or anomalies early such as process failure, equipment failure, fraudulent transactions, disease outbreak, or natural disasters. AI enables prompt and proactive measures to manage and mitigate risks before they become crises.
  • Classification and Regression AI can be used for both classification tasks based on predetermined rules or specifications and regression tasks such as forecasting numbers/prices/market performance

Screenshot 2025-12-01 130644

However, even the AI industry has the humility to recognise that the predictive qualities of AI have limitations:

  • Data Quality Dependency: The accuracy of predictions relies on the quality, completeness, and lack of bias in the training data (the "garbage in, garbage out" principle).
  • Interpretability (the “Black Box” Problem): Many complex AI models, especially deep learning networks, are often considered "black boxes" (A system viewed only by its inputs and outputs without knowing the internal mechanisms), making it difficult to understand exactly how particular predictions are made. Techniques like Explainable AI (XAI) are being developed to address the mystiques of “black boxes.”
  • Ethical Concerns: In the form of biases in sourcing and selection of data can lead to discriminatory or unfair outcomes. Responsible AI practices and regular audits pf sources, selection and deployment of data are required to ensure fairness and compliance with legal, regulatory industry and other standards
  • Prediction Are Not Certainties: Predictive AI measures potential outcomes and likelihoods but not guaranteed certainties. Unexpected and unwanted external factors will always impact real-world results.

How To Address These Limitations?

Data Issues

Adoption of a comprehensive strategy combining people, processes, and technology addresses limitations arising from data quality dependencies. The strategy requires managing the complete lifecycle, from creation to analysis.

At the core a culture of data quality has to be instilled in the enterprise, by educating all employees on the impact of data quality on business outcomes, and best practices for data handling. Accountability and collaboration between technical and business teams are essential as they are in most enterprises.

Addressing data issues at source by measure such as enforcing data entry standards, automating validation checks and root because analysis combined with consolidating information into a single, unified system or database, creating a "single source of truth" are basic steps that apply to all data input applications.

Data will never be perfect. Robust systems are required to detect and correct issues extending to analysis of datasets to understand their current state and identification of their anomalies. Data tools and established procedures can correct existing errors, resolve inconsistencies, remove duplicates and contribute to missing information from trusted external sources.

Data tools should continuously monitor data pipelines for fresh updates, volume, schematic changes, and anomalies in real-time. These tools can actively alert the impacted stakeholders when an issue arises, often before it impacts business operations.

AI should adopt the well-established and honed governance and culture principles applied throughout the data processing industry. They include defining roles and responsibilities for data management, extending to data owners and those who are accountable for specific data domains, supported by escalation policies for data issues

Interpretability (The “Black Box" Problem):

Screenshot 2025-12-01 130932

A prerequisite is to ensure that all models can be reproduced for evidence, analysis and scrutiny for evidential, scrutiny, regulatory and even judicial scenarios

To achieve the capability of interpretation, models should be transparent in design, so that their reasoning process is easier to understand. Complex models by necessity should be broken down into simpler models that can balance performance and transparency.

Data visualisation tools such as consolidated dashboards and heat maps can help understanding of how different variables influence models’ decision-making process.

Before and during model development, the data should be analysed to identify biases or fairness issues that may affect the powers to interpret and provide explanations capable of human understanding. Models’ development and implementation should be analysed so they can be reproduced to help understand their behaviour. Analysis of important features by highlighting those which focus on the input data and conducting decomposition of the models into smaller component parts to identify specific coding features all contribute to understanding the internal workings of the model

Ethical Concerns

To address ethical limitations in AI, it is essential to establish robust governance arrangements, with clear codes of ethics and accountability, as well as transparency through by documented decisions and explanations of outcomes. Evidence should be also be available of the steps taken to mitigating bias in data and algorithms. These steps should be complemented by protection of user privacy through human oversight and diverse development teams, which consider the long-term societal and environmental impact of AI systems.

Governance and accountability should be a goal achieved through establishment of a code of ethics where clear guidelines with the input of various stakeholders to define the values AI systems should follow. The values should include clear accountability clear chain of responsibility ensures who has ownership of actions and the outcomes of AI delivery. The values should be maintained by regular checks on AI systems to ensuring continuous compliance.

Transparency needs to be demonstrated through clear documentation of the logic behind AI decisions so stakeholders can understand AI outcomes. The outcomes need to be articulated in explanations which build trust in the technology.

Trust is established by deployment of diverse datasets that demonstrate fairness and non-discriminatory outcomes, complemented by measures to protect user information and comply with privacy laws. The design of data systems should be benign and, where appropriate, should include human oversight to prevent the AI from taking harmful actions or creating harm. Human oversight is essential to prevent the AI from taking harmful action.

Predictions Are Not Certainties

Screenshot 2025-12-01 131149

It is essential to be explicit about the nature of the prediction itself. Use of language is critical. Words that convey conditionality such as “likely” “probable” and “possible” and” expected “dispel the certainty provided by “will” “” must” “without doubt”. Confidence levels in terms of providing ranges of probability on predictions provide a level of professionalism that dispel tones of soothsaying and fortune telling.

Management of expectations builds trust by clearly representing the source and type of information was used to create the prediction and what limitations the data or the predictive model has. It is similar to stating on the tin the type of ingredient.

Candour about the limitations of the data and the models incorporating the data brings consumer confidence by providing the context and assumptions. Predictions are based on sets of assumptions. By clearly outlining these, others can better understand the potential for error. Whether the assumptions are delivered listing them or explaining the underlying drivers or painting scenarios are techniques applied to different sets of predictions

Predictions seldom remain static but are ever changing situations or hypotheses that are re-evaluated as new information becomes available. In a business context, AI predictions should be promoted and profiled as contributions to inform business decisions and risk management, which can be translated into business actions. Equally, predictions can feed into contingency planning, when they are presented as flexible and adaptable.

Metrics should be developed to measure how and where the decision made employing the prediction has delivered improved results, as quantified by each enterprise.

Conclusions

So what conclusions can we reach on managements of AI data predictions?

  • Adopt a governance culture over data very similar to other forms of data production and management which encompasses rules, processes, procedures and oversight and reporting of data usage and performance.
  • Understand the consumers of predictive AI and their requirements.
  • Be honest and transparent about the capabilities of predictive AI but more importantly its limitations.
  • Predictive AI is not a panacea for managing the future.

Bob McDowall

November 2025

The illustrations in this article were generated using Adobe Express AI Image Generation

svg.lf_footer_svg{ height: 30px; width: 30px; }